Updated 31 October 2026 with fresh prices from Scotland.
Can Costco fuel really save you money? When I first wrote this article in April, the price of filling an average car had jumped by almost 15% in March, and the gap I measured between Costco and Sainsbury’s worked out at 7p a litre. Fuel is still eye wateringly expensive, so I went back to check how the numbers look today.
Firstly, let me call out that, unlike a supermarket or petrol station, not everyone can just go to Costco and fill up. You need to be a member, and eligibility is typically limited to certain sectors such as banking, finance, local government, the Post Office, education, and others. It’s worth checking the latest details before applying (for example, via their Gold Star Membership information page).
There are multiple types of membership, but for this article I’m going to focus on the basic Gold Star Membership, which costs £42 a year, as the aim is to understand fuel savings alone. The Executive Membership costs double at £84 and offers no additional benefits in relation to fuel. Its main advantage is 2% cashback on most Costco purchases, although importantly this excludes fuel, something I’ll cover in more detail in a future article.
Is Costco fuel really cheaper than the supermarkets?
Yes, but by less than it was in the spring. I checked standard unleaded on 31 October 2026 at my local Costco in Scotland, then compared it with a Tesco and an Asda nearby. The Asda price is from close of business the day before.
| Retailer | Unleaded | Costco is cheaper by |
|---|---|---|
| Costco | 164.9p | n/a |
| Tesco | 170.9p | 6.0p a litre |
| Asda | 168.7p | 3.8p a litre |
Fuel prices vary by area, and Costco itself warns that the price at the pump may differ from the price shown online, so treat these as a snapshot rather than a promise. One note on diesel: Costco labels its diesel as premium, at 184.9p, against 192.9p for standard diesel at Tesco and 188.7p at Asda. Those are different grades, so I have stuck to unleaded for the maths below.
How much could you save on each fill up?
How much fuel does an average car actually take? That depends on the size of your car, so I have used three broad categories again: a small car with a 30 litre tank, a medium car with a 52 litre tank and a large car with an 80 litre tank.
| Car size | Tank | Saving per fill up vs Tesco | Saving per fill up vs Asda |
|---|---|---|---|
| Small | 30 litres | £1.80 | £1.14 |
| Medium | 52 litres | £3.12 | £1.98 |
| Large | 80 litres | £4.80 | £3.04 |
To put that in context, filling a medium car costs about £85.75 at Costco against £88.87 at Tesco, so the saving is roughly 3.5%. Against Asda it is closer to 2.3%. A fill up costs somewhere between £50 and £130, but the saving is only a few pounds of it.
Is the £42 Costco membership worth it for fuel alone?
Here is where the maths gets interesting. Whatever the pump price, the number that matters is the gap in pence per litre, and how many litres you buy. At a 6.0p gap you need roughly 700 litres a year to repay the £42. At 3.8p you need about 1,105 litres. As an example only, a car doing 40 miles to the gallon would use that much fuel in around 6,200 and 9,700 miles a year respectively.
| Car size | Fill ups to repay £42 vs Tesco | Fill ups to repay £42 vs Asda |
|---|---|---|
| Small | 24 | 37 |
| Medium | 14 | 22 |
| Large | 9 | 14 |
What this really shows is that the savings are there, but they are not automatic. If you drive a small car and fill up every fortnight, which is about 26 fill ups a year, you would repay the membership against Tesco but not against Asda. A medium car filling up every fortnight repays it against both, while larger cars get there fastest. In simple terms, the more fuel you use, the quicker you benefit.
Don’t forget the convenience factor
It is also important to factor in convenience. My local Costco forecourt is open from 06:00 to 20:00, while the Asda petrol station I checked is open 24 hours, and Costco sites are not as widely available as traditional fuel stations. Any savings need to be weighed against the extra travel time and the odd closed forecourt.
Overall, if you are already eligible for Costco and have a site near you, the fuel savings alone can justify the £42 membership, particularly for medium and larger vehicles and for anyone who fills up regularly. For lighter drivers or those with smaller cars, the savings are still possible, but you will need to be consistent about where you fill up to make it worthwhile.
Frequently asked questions about Costco fuel
Is Costco fuel cheaper than Tesco?
On 31 October 2026, standard unleaded at my local Costco was 164.9p a litre against 170.9p at Tesco, so 6.0p cheaper. Asda was 168.7p, which made Costco 3.8p cheaper. Prices vary by area and change daily, so check before you drive.
How many fill ups does it take to repay the £42 Costco membership?
Against Tesco, a small car needs about 24 fill ups, a medium car about 14 and a large car about 9. Against Asda, which was closer in price, the figures rise to about 37, 22 and 14.
Do you need a membership to use Costco fuel?
Yes. Unlike a supermarket or petrol station, you need to be a member, and eligibility is typically limited to certain sectors such as banking, finance, local government, the Post Office and education. Check the latest details on Costco’s membership page before applying.
Does the Executive Membership save more on fuel?
No. The Executive Membership costs £84 and offers no additional benefits on fuel. Its 2% cashback excludes fuel, so for fuel savings alone the £42 Gold Star Membership is the one to compare.
Is Costco diesel cheaper too?
Costco labels its diesel as premium and it was 184.9p, against 192.9p for standard diesel at Tesco and 188.7p at Asda. Those are different grades, so it is not a like for like comparison.
I keep an eye on petrol every month in my Sensible Basket September 2026 results, and you can follow the trend on the Sensible Basket price tracker. If you shop at Tesco anyway, my Tesco Clubcard review covers the points you earn on fuel there, and my supermarket loyalty cards guide compares all the major schemes. For more ways to trim everyday costs, head to my Spending Habits: Small Changes, Bigger Savings page.
As with most things when it comes to saving money, the key is consistency. Do you fill up at Costco, or is the supermarket forecourt close enough?

One thought on “Costco Fuel: Is the £42 Membership Worth It for Fuel Alone?”